Fay’s Restaurant

Reviews

• Jamie P.

  star star star star star 9 June 2026

  Excellent!  The bread is fresh & delicious and comes with traditional oil & garlic dip.   We enjoyed it to the point of having seconds.  Everything is fresh and locally sourced.  I had the pizza and my husband had the Pasta Margherita.  The portion sizes were great, everything was fresh, and the service was great!  We both very much enjoyed our meals.
  
  I am a Sicilian American girl and I eat my pizza a certain way.  Aside from thick crust (which no one around here does), I like a lot of sauce and very light cheese.  Most places don't get this order correct.  Fay's nailed it the first time & it was really appreciated.  The pizza also had a great crust that wasn't too thin at all.
  
  My husband's Pasta Magherita had cherry tomatoes,  mozzarella,  fresh basil, fresh scallion, & a scampi sauce.  It was all very fresh and extremely yummy.
  
  After our entrees, we opted for dessert from the specials menu.  We each ordered Bailey's Cheesecake.   Oh, my God!  If & when you have the opportunity to have this dessert, HAVE IT!  
  
  As for the service:  EXCELLENT!  There were quite a few people in dining room and still we waited for nothing and felt like the only people in the restaurant.  Thanks Charlene!  You rock!

• Douglas T.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 6 June 2026

  WoW I ordered a 3 topping pizza and it hardly had any toppings on it if you're going to charge $12.50 for that size pizza don't be so skimpy on the toppings maybe you can make good for this so disappointed

• BeckyScott B.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  Well, we don't go there often and in the few times we've eaten there it's been "OK", but not so much tonight with our take-out. I got a BBQ chicken wrap w/ fries and hubby got the fish taco w/ sweet potato fries ... we ordered a side order of cole slaw, cause hubby LOVES cole slaw, and do you want to know what he thought of his cole slaw??? Hmm ... he'd like to know too cause HE DIDN'T GET IT. So we ordered it and paid for it, but didn't receive it. Didn't know till we got home, of course. And when we opened his container of food we actually wasn't sure what it was. Come to find out you have to put the meal together yourself, it's all apart.
  
  So needless to say, if we ever do get take-out from there again I'll be ripping the bag open in the place 1st to make sure we actually get everything we ordered. I know it's only cole slaw, but when you purposely order something cause you actually wanted it and get home ready to eat it and you see your food and it's basically a DIY kit and you're missing something you wanted ... it's disappointing.
  
  If we go again at any time we'll eat in, no take-out.

• Suzanne E.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 3 June 2026

  Ordered the fish tacos and was disapointed. They looked and tasted like they were from the frozen food section of the supermarket. The people that worked there were pleasant.

• Shawn D.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 25 May 2026

  Vegan review:
  
  I have been to Fay's twice in the past two weeks. Once for my grandmother's 89th birthday and once with my friend's family. Both times I was underwhelmed. I was served the same pasta both times. It looked delicious but it tasted rather bland. (Gluten free pasta is never great in my opinion.) The second time, our waitress wasn't great, she seemed kind of put off by my questions. Like I was causing her too much trouble by asking. When I asked about the Yelp coupon that popped up when I checked in, the waitress said, "that isn't a coupon we honor...". WHAT!?! It's in the app for your restaurant. Give me a break. The first time our waitresses were great.
  Overall, a bland experience, given that some amazing restaurants are popping up in Dartmouth and NB, you'd really think that Fay's would be trying to keep up. I like to support local businesses, but I doubt I'll be coming back here by choice.